The 9 Best Grill Trays and Pans for Home Chefs

grill tray

Last Updated - November 22, 2022

Best Overall
Made In Cookware Carbon Steel Griddle with Leather Sleeves thumbnail

 4.8/5

Budget Friendly
Xtrema Grill Pan thumbnail

 5/5

If you've yet to add a grill tray to your collection of cooking tools and gadgets, now's the time! Designed for use on the stovetop, under the broiler, and on your barbeque grill, they're made with materials that can withstand the high temperatures required to create crisp exteriors and perfect sear marks.

To help you shop, we're highlighting our picks for the best grill trays and pans for your kitchen. All of the products included are made using non-toxic materials and PFOA-free, PTFE-free, non-stick finishes that meet the demands of everyday life.

The 9 Best Grilling Trays, Pans, and Griddles

Made In Cookware Carbon Steel Griddle with Leather Sleeves

Best Overall

Made In Cookware Carbon Steel Griddle with Leather Sleeves

Source: Made In

Made in Cookware's Carbon Steel Griddle was designed to mimic a restaurant flat-top, maximizing direct heat contact for crispy edges. The versatile grill tray has been called "restaurant workhouse for your kitchen" by The New York Times and "what the pros use" by the Wall Street Journal.

Its modern carbon steel material combines the best qualities of cast iron and stainless steel: excellent heat retention, even heat distribution, and a naturally non-stick surface. Slip the Italian leather sleeves over the hand-welded raised handles for ergonomic carrying and added style. Designed to withstand a lifetime of frequent use, it's the perfect gift for the home chef in your life.

Pros:

  • Naturally non-stick and its seasoned with vegetable oil
  • Safe up to 1200F
  • Easy to clean
  • It can be used on the stove top

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • Hand wash only

FINEX Seasoned Cast Iron Lean Grill Pan

Best Value

FINEX Seasoned Cast Iron Lean Grill Pan

Source: Williams Sonoma

The FINEX Seasoned Cast-Iron Lean Grill Pan makes lean, low-fat grilling easy— without or without a barbeque out back. Each heirloom-quality pan is handcrafted by skilled artisans at a small factory in Tennessee, where it's preseasoned with organic flaxseed oil for a natural non-stick finish. Hand wash and care for it just like your other cast iron cookware.

Measuring 15.5 inches X 9 inches, it fits nicely on a single stovetop burner, under the broiler, or on the side of the grill. Use it for cooking vegetables, seafood, meats, and anything else your culinary imagination can come up with. A convenient corner spout makes it easy to pour off extra drippings when you're finished.

Pros:

  • Pre-seasoned with flaxseed oil
  • It can be used on any type of cooktop, including induction
  • Safe up to 500F

Cons:

  • Hand wash only

Xtrema Grill Pan

Budget Friendly

Xtrema Grill Pan

Source: Xtrema

Take your barbequing abilities to the next level with this best-selling Grill Pan by Xtrema. The 100% ceramic tray is handcrafted by specialty Chinese artisans using high-quality materials and a non-toxic, non-stick finish.

The time-tested material can withstand extreme temperatures and conditions, meaning it's safe for use on the BBQ, in the microwave, and under the broiler in your oven. Plus, it can handle a trip through the dishwasher for easy clean-up and the freezer for quick cool-downs. Use it to make a crispy barbecue pizza on your outdoor grill, fire-roasted vegetables under the broiler, and perfectly-seared burgers and seafood in the oven.

Pros:

  • Non-toxic, metal-free, and sustainably made
  • Teflon, PFOA, and PFAS free non-stick coatings
  • It can be used on a BBQ grill, over the fire, or the microwave
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • The size can be small for a family

Staub Enamelware Square Grill Pan

Premium Choice

Staub Enamelware Square Grill Pan

Source: Perigold

Sandwich lovers, it's time to upgrade your bulky panini press to this Staub Enamel Square Grill Pan. The versatile pan features an enamel-coated cooking surface for better browning, braising, and roasting capabilities. Prepare for the crispiest, gooiest grilled cheese sandwiches ever!

The PTFE- and PFOA-free pan is safe to use on all stovetop heat sources, including gas, electric, and induction. Plus, the colorful enamel glaze adds a pop of color to your stovetop— all without any toxic dyes or chemicals.

Pros:

  • PTFE and PFOA free
  • Oven and grill safe for up to 500F
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • It is not non-stick
  • Pan can feel heavy
  • Expensive

GreenPan Premiere Stainless-Steel Ceramic Non-Stick Round Grill Pan

Most Versatile

GreenPan Premiere Stainless-Steel Ceramic Non-Stick Round Grill Pan

Source: Williams Sonoma

This GreenPan Premiere Stainless-Steel Ceramic Non-Stick Round Grill Pan makes a practical solution for apartment dwellers without a proper barbeque. The round grill pan is cast with deep ridges for strong sear marks and elevation above drippings. Its PFOA-free Diamond Advanced non-stick ceramic coating is protected by a unique wrapped-rim design that prevents chips and extends product life.

The do-it-all grill pan is dishwasher-safe and heat-resistant up to 600°F, on the stovetop, in the oven, and under the broiler. Its innovative Evershine finish keeps the polished stainless steel exterior looking new, even after years of use. Best of all, its sturdy three-ply construction and durable non-stick coating are safe for use with metal utensils.

Pros:

  • Non-toxic and free of PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium
  • Safe for use with metal utensils
  • Heat-resistant to 600°F
  • Easy to clean, dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • Expensive

Ooni Cast Iron Grizzler Pan

Best Grill Pan

Ooni Cast Iron Grizzler Pan

Source: Crate & Barrel

Though designed for use in the brand's outdoor pizza ovens, Ooni's Cast Iron Grizzler Pan makes an excellent option for everyday cooking on the stovetop or grill. A beechwood serving board included with the cast iron pan makes it easy to go straight from the BBQ or broiler to the table for an impressive dinner party display.

Use the removable handle latches onto either side of the pan to safely pull it out of the hot oven or off the grill. Take it off for compact storage in between uses. The beechwood tray can be used underneath other hot pans to protect your counter or tabletop during serving.

Pros:

  • Super easy to clean and season
  • Imparts beautiful grill marks on whatever you are cooking
  • It can be used on the stovetop, oven, grill, or pizza oven
  • It has small holes at the end of the pan, and handle latches can move it

Cons:

  • Will need to be seasoned
  • It can feel a little small
  • Can feel heavy

Greenpan GP5 Infinite8 Ceramic Nonstick Round Grill Pan

Premium Choice

Greenpan GP5 Infinite8 Ceramic Nonstick Round Grill Pan

Source: GreenPan

The search is over. Greenpan GP5 Infinite8 Ceramic Nonstick Round Grill Pan is guaranteed to be your new go-to cooking tool. The versatile round pan is constructed from durable ceramic with a cutting-edge non-stick coating that is utensil safe and free of PFOA and PFOA. At 11 inches wide, it's the perfect size for chicken breasts, steaks, seafood, pork chops, and even larger foods.

This grill pan is optimized for performance on all stovetops, including induction. Safe up to 600˚F, this pan is built for serious home cooking and makes stovetop-to-oven cooking simple. And when you are done cooking, place it in the dishwasher.

Pros:

  • Easy to clean. Dishwasher safe
  • Safe up to 600˚F
  • Metal utensil safe, free of PFAS & PFOA

Cons:

  • Expensive

Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Double-Burner Reversible Grill/Griddle

Best Multi-Purpose

Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Double-Burner Reversible Grill or Griddle

Source: Williams Sonoma

Brunch will be your new favorite meal to cook thanks to the Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Double-Burner Reversible Grill/Griddle. Equipped with a flat surface on one side and deep, grill-like ridges on the other, it can whip up pancakes, bacon, hash browns, eggs, and more!

The versatile grill tray is forged by America's oldest family-owned cookware foundry using non-toxic, naturally non-stick cast iron that transfers and retains heat easily. Two large handles allow for easy lifting, and a raised lip around the edge helps prevent spills. It's stovetop-, oven-, and broiler-safe, so your cooking possibilities are truly endless. Don't be afraid to reach for the tray again when dinner time rolls around.

Pros:

  • Seasoned with 100% natural vegetable oil
  • Use in the oven, on the stove, on the grill, or over a campfire
  • Long enough to cover two burners

Cons:

  • It may not heat evenly
  • The surface can feel too narrow

Xtrema Round Roasting Tray

Best For Roasting

Xtrema Round Roasting Tray

Source: Xtrema

The Round Roasting Tray from Xtrema has made cooking fun. Its 100% ceramic round roasting tray will elevate your cooking skill when used as a bone broth insert, grill pan, roasting rack, or toaster oven pan. The possibilities are endless.

Like all of Xtrema's cookware, the versatile grill tray is made without metals and is always 100% non-toxic. Unlike metal or non-stick cookware, pure ceramic does not leach heavy metals or unwanted toxicants into the food. Xtrema's roasting tray is free of Teflon, PFOA, PFAS, non-stick coatings, or a metal core. Each piece is handcrafted by specialty Chinese ceramic artists, and it is perfect for throwing on the BBQ grill, over a fire, in a microwave, or in the dishwasher.

Pros:

  • Certified PFOA-free, PTFE- free, no extractable lead or cadmium
  • Even heating and excellent thermal retention
  • Microwave, oven, BBQ, freezer, and dishwasher safe
  • Scratch-resistant and stain proof

Cons:

  • It can feel a little small

What is a grill tray used for?

As the name suggests, a grill tray is designed to recreate the crisp edges and strong sear marks of an outdoor grill. They're great for apartment dwellers and homes without a proper grill out back. While most grilling trays can be used for multiple cooking methods, double-check the product information to ensure it can withstand the extreme heat of a barbeque or broiler.

On the Stovetop

A grill tray can be used on the stovetop to mimic an outdoor grill or restaurant flat top. Treat it just as you would a cast iron pan. Here are a few popular ways to use a grill pan to get you started:

  • Crisp up the edges of grilled cheese sandwiches and paninis

  • Create sizzling, restaurant-style fajitas that can go straight from the stovetop to the table

  • Create an even crisp on hashbrowns and breakfast potatoes

  • Griddle cook pancakes and sunny-side-up eggs

  • Minimize the fat content of bacon and sausage by elevating it above the drippings it creates

In the Oven and Under the Broiler

Most grill pans can be placed under the broiler to help get a crispy finish on top. Just be sure to double-check the maximum temperature your tray can be used at beforehand. Here's a glimpse at the multitude of ways to use a grill pan in the oven:

  • "Grill" peppers, onions, and other vegetables without a barbecue

  • Re-crisp the crust of a leftover pizza

  • Create strong sear marks on steaks, hamburgers, pork chops, and poultry

  • Keep fish filets in one piece

  • Perfectly bake brie or halloumi cheese

  • Create an extra crispy crust on garlic bread and bruschetta

On the Barbeque

A grill tray can be an incredibly helpful tool for cooking smaller foods on the barbeque. Used as a grill topper, its large, flat surface prevents pieces from falling between the grates— all without the mountain of tin foil previously required. Here are a few ways to upgrade your grilling experience with your new pan:

  • Create even sear marks on skewers, kabobs, and small cuts of meat

  • Prevent small, skinny vegetables like asparagus, bell pepper slices, and onion rings from falling between the grill grates

  • Keep delicate fish filets from breaking apart

  • Prevent peaches, pineapple, and other grill-able fruits from burning

  • Create an evenly cooked, perfectly crisp crust on your barbequed pizza

Disclaimer: This post includes affiliate links. This means I make a few dollars if you purchase/sign up after clicking my link. This costs you nothing, but it helps keep this blog running!


You may also like

heart veggie

Be A Happier & Healthier You

Start Your Self Care Journey Today And Get A FREE Weekly Self Care Check List 

>