A Guide to The 13 Best Non-Toxic Casserole Dish Selections

Casserole Dish

Last Updated - October 31, 2022

Best for Holiday Baking
Le Creuset Pumpkin Casserole Dish thumbnail

 4.6/5

Best for Baked Goods
Caraway Rectangle Pan thumbnail

 4.9/5

The term casserole can refer to any dish baked in the oven in a deep, wide container— making a casserole dish one of the most versatile bakeware pieces you could possibly own. Use it for cooking lasagna for dinner, crisping up leftovers, roasting meat, serving up cheesy gratin, or even baking a delicious dessert.

In this guide to non-toxic casserole dishes, we'll answer commonly asked questions about and highlight some of the best options on the bakeware market today. It goes without saying your new baking dish will get plenty of use when the holiday season rolls around. Be sure to check the size and material, as it will affect how much food you can cook, how it comes out, and how easy it is to clean up.

What is a casserole dish?

A casserole dish is a large baking dish that doubles as a serving vessel. Most are round, square, or rectangular, with deep sides and practical carrying handles, and some come equipped with a functional lid for baking and storage.

These versatile pieces are designed to go straight from the oven to the table— and then to the fridge, microwave, or dishwasher after. Consider it a must-have for any home chef or budding baker.

What Is a Casserole Dish Made Of?

Casserole dishes are traditionally made from porcelain, ceramic, glass, or earthenware— often finished with a non-stick coating for fast, easy clean-up. Stick to baking dishes labeled as free from BPA, PFAs, PFOA, PTFE, heavy metals, and other toxic chemicals that can leach into your food as it cooks.

The 11 Best Casserole Dish Selections That are Non-Toxic

Our Place Ovenware Set

Best Overall

Our Place Ovenware Set

Source: Our Place

Set yourself up for success in the kitchen with the Our Place Ovenware Set. The five-piece collection features the brand's ultra-versatile Oven Pan, a trio of stoneware casserole dishes, and a reusable Oven Mat. After baking, roasting, braising, searing, and serving your meal to perfection, they fit neatly together to maximize storage space. With six stylish color options to choose from, this is one of the best casserole dishes. It's an excellent gift for newlyweds, first-time apartment dwellers, and foodies short on cabinet space.

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • Beautiful bakeware
  • Great non-stick as food does not stick to the pan
  • Ergonomic side handles are easy to grip even thick oven mitts

Cons:

  • Pricey

Le Creuset Pumpkin Casserole Dish

Best for Holiday Baking

Le Creuset Pumpkin Casserole Dish

Source: Le Creuset

Le Creuset's Pumpkin Casserole Dish makes a charming addition to any holiday table. Inspired by timeless fairy tales, the charming vessel features a lid fashioned into the shape of a pumpkin. It's crafted from colorful glazed stoneware that's oven, microwave, broiler, metal utensil, and dishwasher-safe. Measuring nine inches in diameter, the small round casserole dish is perfect for green bean casserole, potatoes au gratin, and other side dishes. Take it straight from the oven to the table to truly wow your guests.

Pros:

  • Durable porcelain enamel glaze resists chips, scratches, and stains
  • Easy to clean, and it is dishwasher safe
  • Versatile. It can be used in the microwave, oven, freezer
  • A beautiful addition to your dining table

Cons:

  • It doesn't have a handle and can be hard to handle

Caraway Rectangle Pan

Best for Baked Goods

Caraway Rectangle Pan

Source: Caraway

The all-purpose Caraway Rectangle Pan makes an excellent addition to any baker's repertoire. Deep sides and even heat distribution make it an excellent option for brownies, fruit cobblers, cakes, and all the bars and barks your creativity can conjure up this holiday season. Like all of Caraway's eco-friendly cookware, it's crafted from a mineral-based, non-stick coating that won't leach toxic chemicals into your dessert as it cooks. Might we suggest overhauling your collection of baking dishes with the 11-piece Bakeware Set?

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • Food doesn't stick at all
  • Good quality

Cons:

  • Pricey

GreenPan Premiere Ovenware Ceramic Non-Stick Rectangular Baker

Best Non-Stick

GreenPan Premiere Ovenware Ceramic Non-Stick Rectangular Baker

Source: GreenPan

Short on cabinet space? Streamline your bakeware repertoire with the GreenPan Premiere Ovenware Ceramic Non-Stick Rectangular Baker. The rectangular lid double-duties as a sheet pan, allowing you to bake two dishes at once. Uncover your casserole or lasagna halfway through, and use the convertible lid to roast vegetables, potatoes, or cheesy garlic bread to serve on the side. Both versatile pans feature durable cast aluminum construction with reinforced rims, built-in handles, and a healthy non-stick coating made without PFAs or PFOA. Extend the life of your new favorite bakeware by sticking to silicone utensils and hand-washing— though they're dishwasher-safe for those in a hurry.

Pros:

  • Versatile tool
  • It can be used split up or together
  • Built-in handles for easy grabbing when wearing oven mitts
  • Easy to clean as it is dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • Pricey

Pillivuyt Porcelain Rectangular Roasters

Best for Roasts

Pillivuyt Porcelain Rectangular Roasters

Source: Williams Sonoma

French chefs are known to cook roasts and large cuts of meat, poultry, and seafood in deep porcelain dishes like these Porcelain Rectangular Roasters from Pillivuyt. Left unglazed on the bottom, the high-fired porcelain material conducts heat more gently than metal and cleans more easily. Each restaurant-quality pan is crafted in France by a renowned cookware manufacturer with over 200 years of experience. Both the No. 0 and No. 1 sizes are worthy of a place in your pantry.

Pros:

  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe
  • Versatile. It can be in the microwave, freezer, and oven
  • Durable and will last for a long time

Cons:

  • Pricey

Crate & Barrel Lucerne Casserole Dishes

Best Round Baking Dishes

Crate & Barrel Lucerne Casserole Dishes

Source: Crate & Barrel

Crate & Barrel's Lucerne Casserole Dishes are a budget-friendly option that doesn't sacrifice quality or style. The two all-purpose lidded casserole dishes are constructed from classic glazed white porcelain with looped handles and lids for easy carrying, serving, and storage. Use the three-quart dish for your main casserole and its one-quart companion for a delicious side dish. Now all that's left to do is pick your recipes! They're safe to use in the oven (up to 400°F), microwave, dishwasher, and freezer, so your options are endless.

Pros:

  • Affordable price point
  • Microwave and oven safe
  • Easy to clean. Dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • Will need to handle with care

Le Creuset Heritage Ceramic Baking Dish with Lid

Worth the Splurge

Le Creuset Heritage Ceramic Baking Dish with Lid

Source: Crate & Barrel

The French cookware brand Le Creuset has been a favorite among celebrity chefs, food bloggers, luxury restaurateurs, and home cooks alike since its debut in 1925. It offers superior heat retention, durability, and good looks.

This Le Creuset Lidded Heritage Ceramic Baking Dish is crafted from dense, enamel-glazed stoneware that resists stains and scratches, releases stuck-on food easily, and blocks moisture absorption to prevent cracking. Its colorful glaze and minimalist, utilitarian form look striking on any tabletop.

Pros:

  • A variety of attractive colors to choose from
  • Convenient and versatile
  • Easy to clean

Cons:

  • Expensive

Pyrex Deep Baking Dish

Best on a Budget

Pyrex Deep Baking Dish

Source: Crate & Barrel

This Deep Baking Dish is an oversized version of a classic Pyrex piece. The extra deep baking dish boasts 3.25-inch-high sides and built-in handles to accommodate large roasts, heavy lasagnas, and deep-dish cobblers. Crafted from Pyrex's signature tempered glass, it won't stain or absorb food odors. Plus, it's microwave-, freezer-, and dishwasher-safe. Priced at less than $20, this pan is hard to beat on a budget.

Pros:

  • Affordable price
  • Easy clean-up and dishwasher safe
  • It takes up minimal storage space
  • Heavy duty and good quality

Cons:

  • Handle with care

Staub 4-Piece Baking Set

Best Set

Staub 4-Piece Baking Set

Source: Crate & Barrel

Master the art of the dinner party with Staub's 4-Piece Baking Set. The innovative cookware label draws on French culinary tradition to serve up some of the best oven-to-table dishes available. This versatile set features an ovular, rectangular, and square baking dish with a lid. Each piece is crafted from classic white porcelain with a protective enamel glaze and sleek handles. Prepare to be amazed by what you cook up!

Pros:

  • The perfect size for a family of two
  • Heats evenly
  • Easy to clean
  • The bottom of the dishes are smooth and do not damage the stone countertop

Cons:

  • Pricey

Xtrema Rectangular Baking Pan

Most Versatile

Xtrema Rectangular Baking Pan

Source: Xtrema

Xtrema's Rectangular Baking Pan is a reliable addition to your daily cooking routine. Each 100% ceramic pan is handmade by skilled Chinese artisans using a healthy non-stick coating that won't leach unwanted heavy metals or chemicals into your food. Use it for baking casseroles, lasagna, cakes, and beyond. Available in three size options, the ceramic pans will quickly become a family heirloom in the kitchen. They'll last for decades to come with proper care.

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • The small size can fit in a toaster oven
  • Sturdy and versatile

Cons:

  • Expensive

West Elm Ensemble Cork Bakeware

Best for serving

West Elm Ensemble Cork Bakeware

Source: West Elm

West Elm's Ensemble Cork Bakeware is designed to go straight from the oven to the table— and impress all your dinner guests when it does. The ovular casserole dish is crafted in Portugal with a stoneware body and lid set atop a 100% natural cork tray. After dinner, it can be washed in the dishwasher, tucked away in the freezer, or heated up in the microwave for a second helping. Not to mention, it looks great on your TikTok or Instagram feed.

Pros:

  • Perfectly suited for oven-to-table serving
  • Oven, microwave, and freezer safe
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • Pricey

Emile Henry French Ceramic Potter Rectangular Baker

Best Heat Distribution

Emile Henry French Ceramic Potter Rectangular Baker

Source: Williams Sonoma

The Potter Collection from Emilie Henry recalls the casserole dishes of decades past. Crafted in France from the brand's signature Burgundian clay, it absorbs, distributes, and retains heat evenly to bake content to perfection and keep your finished dish warm at the table. The hand-applied ceramic glaze will not chip, crack, craze, or absorb odors or flavors during baking. Round out your bakeware collection with the coordinating Ceramic Potter Square Baker, Loaf Pan, and Pie Dish. Together, they can tackle any meal.

Pros:

  • Exceptional heat-retention
  • The durable hand-applied glaze will not chip, crack or craze over time
  • It does not absorb odors or flavors
  • Microwavable; oven, broiler, freezer, and dishwasher safe.

Cons:

  • Pricey

Williams Sonoma Thermo-Clad Stainless-Steel Ovenware Baking Pan

Best Metal Casserole Dish

Williams Sonoma Thermo-Clad Stainless-Steel Ovenware Baking Pan

Source: Williams Sonoma

Though most casserole dishes are made from porcelain or glass, there are a few options on the market for chefs who prefer metal pans. Williams Sonoma's Thermo-Clad Stainless-Steel Ovenware Baking Pan draws on five decades of culinary experience. Made from an innovative Thermo-Clad™ material, it transfers heat evenly and efficiently for uniform results. Use it for brownies, layer cakes, pasta bakes, and every casserole your heart pleases. This versatile pan can handle it all!

Pros:

  • Thermo-Clad technology ensures efficient, uniform heating
  • Made with a durable stainless-steel interior, stainless-steel exterior, and a heat-sensitive aluminum core
  • Side handles offer a steady grip – even when wearing oven mitts
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • Pricey

What can you make in a casserole dish?

The beauty of a casserole dish is that it can be used to cook almost anything. Thanks to its practical size and depth, it can whip up:

  • Green bean, tater tot, or tuna noodle casserole

  • Lasagna

  • Chicken pot pie

  • Moussaka

  • Enchiladas

  • Baked macaroni and cheese

  • Roasted squash

  • Manicotti and stuffed pasta shells

  • Roasted vegetables

  • Pot roast

  • Whole roasted chicken

How big should a casserole dish be?

If you're following a recipe, it should specify the size and shape of the dish you should be using. As a rule of thumb, only fill the container 3/4 of the way to help minimize your chances of it overflowing when cooking. Always place a metal baking sheet on the rack below to catch drips and spills before they burn on the bottom of your oven.

Disclaimer: This post includes affiliate links. This means I make a few dollars if you purchase/sign up after clicking my link. This costs you nothing, but it helps keep this blog running!


You may also like

heart veggie

Be A Happier & Healthier You

Start Your Self Care Journey Today And Get A FREE Weekly Self Care Check List 

>