- Best On A Budget | Pyrex | Find on Amazon
- Most Versatile | Xtrema | Find on Xtrema
- Best Deep Casserole Dish | Anchor Hocking | Find on Amazon
- Best Family-Friendly Casserole Dish | DaTerra Cucina | Find on Amazon
The term casserole can refer to any dish baked in the oven in a deep, wide container— making a casserole dish one of the most versatile bakeware pieces you could possibly own. Use it for cooking lasagna for dinner, crisping leftovers, roasting meat, serving cheesy gratin, or even baking a delicious dessert.
In this guide to non-toxic casserole dishes, we'll answer commonly asked questions about and highlight some of the best options on the bakeware market today. It goes without saying your new baking dish will get plenty of use when the holiday season rolls around. Be sure to check the size and material, as it will affect how much food you can cook, how it comes out, and how easy it is to clean up.
What To Look For When Shopping For A Casserole Dish
Material
Casserole dishes are traditionally made from porcelain, ceramic, glass, or earthenware. Each material has its own benefits. Ceramic and glass baking dishes are popular choices as they provide even heat distribution and are generally oven-safe. Cast iron offers excellent heat retention but is heavier.
Many of these casserole dishes are often finished with a non-stick coating or glazing for fast, easy cleanup. However, many of these coatings and glazes contain metal and nanoparticles that can leach into your dish during high-heat cooking. It's best to seek a casserole dish with no coating or glazing to avoid metal and nanoparticles. Or seek casserole dishes from brands that disclose the coating and glazing material. Look for ones free from BPA, PFAs, PFOA, PTFE, heavy metals, and other toxic chemicals.
Size and Capacity
Consider the size of your typical casseroles or the number of servings you need to accommodate when selecting the appropriate roasting dish. Casserole dishes come in various sizes and capacities, ranging from small individual servings to large family-sized options. Ensure the dish can hold the desired amount of food and fits your oven for proper cooking.
Shape
Casserole dishes can be round, rectangular, square, or oval, and the shape may affect the cooking and presentation of your dish. Rectangular or square dishes are suitable for layered casseroles, while round or oval dishes work well for stir-fried or mixed casseroles.
Handles and Lids
Look for casserole dishes with sturdy handles for easy carrying, especially when hot. Some dishes have matching lids that help retain heat and moisture during cooking, and a tight-fitting lid is beneficial for slow cooking or transporting your dish.
Heat Resistance
Ensure the casserole dish is oven-safe and can withstand the desired cooking temperatures. Most dishes are labeled with their heat resistance levels, so check the manufacturer's guidelines.
Durability
Consider the durability of the casserole dish. Look for dishes that are resistant to chipping, cracking, and staining. High-quality materials and reputable brands often offer better durability.
Cleaning and Maintenance
For easy cleaning, checking if the casserole dish is dishwasher-safe is recommended. Some materials or finishes may require hand washing. While non-stick surfaces can facilitate easier cleaning, it's important to note that they may gradually wear off with extended use.
Versatility
Evaluate the versatility of the casserole dish by considering its suitability for various cooking purposes, including baking, roasting, and serving. A versatile dish can be a valuable addition to your kitchen.
Aesthetics
Consider the design and color of the casserole dish, especially if you plan to use it for serving at the table. Select a style that complements your kitchen decor or aligns with your personal preferences when choosing a casserole dish.
Budget
Finally, consider your budget. Casserole dishes come in a wide price range, and while higher-priced options may offer better quality and durability, there are also affordable choices that can fulfill your needs.
The 7 Best Casserole Dish Selections That Are Non-Toxic
Our Place Ovenware Set
Best Overall
Source: Our Place
Set yourself up for success in the kitchen with the Our Place Ovenware Set. The five-piece collection features the brand's ultra-versatile Oven Pan, a trio of chip-resistant stoneware casserole dishes, and a reusable Oven Mat.
From baking scrumptious lasagnas to baking your favorite banana bread, these casserole dishes are designed to tackle any culinary task. Their heat resistance of up to 450°F allows for a wide range of cooking techniques, from slow and steady braising to high-heat searing. Whether you're using them in the oven, broiler, or even on the stovetop, these dishes can handle it all. After baking, roasting, braising, searing, and serving your meal to perfection, they fit neatly together to maximize storage space.
The Ovenware Set is expertly crafted with a perfect balance of style and durability, exuding an undeniable elegance. The set includes two casserole dishes in different sizes, allowing you to effortlessly transition from cooking intimate meals to hosting large gatherings. This baking dish's generously sized loop handles make it a breeze to grasp, even when wearing thick oven mitts. The sleek, modern design and choice of neutral colors make these dishes an attractive addition to any kitchen decor. With six stylish color options to choose from, this is one of the best casserole dishes. It's an excellent gift for newlyweds, first-time apartment dwellers, and foodies short on cabinet space.
Our Ratings
Overall Rating: 4.8/5 Ease Of Cleaning: 4.7/5 Durability: 4.8/5 Value for Money: 4.7/5 Ease of Use: 4.8/5 Ergonomic: 4.6/5
Materials | Stoneware |
Dimensions | 20.9 in. (with handle) x 11.8 in. x 1.8 in.; 4.52 lbs.; 5 qt. capacity |
Capacity | 1.5, 2, 3.5, and 5 qt. capacity |
Dishwasher Safe | No |
Features | Free of PFOAs, PTFEs, other PFAS, lead, cadmium, toxic metals, and nanoparticles |
Pros:
Cons:
Caraway Rectangle Pan
Best for Baked Goods
Source: Caraway
The all-purpose Caraway Rectangle Pan makes an excellent addition to any baker's repertoire. Whether you're searing a perfectly juicy steak or sautéing a medley of vegetables, this pan delivers consistent, delicious results. The deep sides and even heat distribution make it an excellent option for brownies, fruit cobblers, cakes, and all the bars and barks your creativity can conjure up this holiday season. The ergonomic stainless steel handle ensures a comfortable grip, providing ease of maneuverability and control while cooking.
Caraway's eco-friendly cookware is crafted from a mineral-based and non-stick coating free from harmful chemicals like PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium. It won't leach toxic chemicals into your dessert as it cooks. Experience the benefits of the ceramic coating in the Ovenware Set, as it guarantees effortless food release. This feature enables you to prepare healthier meals by reducing the need for excessive oil or butter. Cleaning up is a breeze, as even the most stubborn culinary creations slide off the pan's surface effortlessly. With the Ovenware Set, you can spend less time scrubbing and more time enjoying the delightful flavors of your culinary creations.
Our Ratings
Overall Rating: 4.8/5 Ease Of Cleaning: 4.5/5 Durability: 4.8/5 Value for Money: 4.6/5 Ease of Use: 4.8/5 Ergonomic: 4.6/5
Materials | Non-Stick Ceramic, Aluminized Steel Body + Stainless Steel Handles |
Dimensions | N/A |
Capacity | N/A |
Dishwasher Safe | No |
Features | Free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAs, and heavy metals |
Pros:
Cons:
GreenPan Premiere Ovenware Ceramic Non-Stick Rectangular Baker
Best Casserole Dish With Lid
Source: GreenPan
Short on cabinet space? Streamline your bakeware repertoire with the GreenPan Premiere Ovenware Ceramic Non-Stick Rectangular Baker. This rectangular baker comes complete with a convenient lid, allowing you to seal in flavors and moisture while baking. The tight-fitting lid is also handy for storing leftovers or transporting your dishes to potlucks or family gatherings. Additionally, the baker features sturdy handles that provide a secure grip for easy handling, even when wearing oven mitts.
Built with a durable cast aluminum construction, this baker offers superior heat distribution and retention. This feature ensures that your baked goods cook evenly, resulting in a delightful golden brown finish. Whether you're baking casseroles, lasagnas, or sheet cakes, you can trust this baker to deliver consistent results every time.
Cleanup is a breeze with the GreenPan Rectangular Baker. The non-stick coating of the Ovenware Set is crafted without PFAs or PFOA, guaranteeing that food effortlessly slides off the surface. As a result, you can save valuable time on scrubbing and focus on savoring your delicious culinary creations. For added convenience in busy households, the baker in the Ovenware Set is dishwasher-safe. Simply place it in the dishwasher for effortless cleaning, saving you time and effort in the kitchen. Extend the life of your new favorite bakeware by hand-washing.
Our Ratings
Overall Rating: 4.8/5 Ease Of Cleaning: 4.9/5 Durability: 4.9/5 Value for Money: 4.7/5 Ease of Use: 4.8/5 Ergonomic: 4.6/5
Materials | Ceramic non-stick and cast aluminum construction |
Dimensions | 13" x 9" |
Capacity | N/A |
Dishwasher Safe | yes |
Features | Free of PFAS and PFOA |
Pros:
Cons:
Pyrex Easy Grab 2-Qt Glass Casserole Dish with Lid
Best on a Budget
Source: Target
The Pyrex 2-Quart Glass Casserole Dish is a reliable and versatile companion for any home cook. Not to mention, priced at less than $20, this casserole dish is hard to beat on a budget. The Pyrex 2-Quart Glass Casserole Dish offers remarkable versatility. From casseroles and baked pasta dishes to roasted vegetables and desserts, this dish is perfect for an array of culinary creations. It transitions seamlessly from oven to table, allowing you to serve your delicious creations with style and convenience.
Pyrex has been synonymous with durability, and this 2-quart casserole dish lives up to that reputation. Crafted from high-quality tempered glass, it withstands the test of time and maintains its integrity through countless baking sessions. This dish is built to last, ensuring reliable performance for years to come.
Thanks to the transparent glass construction, you can effortlessly monitor the progress of your cooking. The clear visibility provided by the glass allows you to keep a close eye on your dishes without the need to open the oven or remove the lid. Whether you're watching the golden crust of a casserole or a cake is perfectly baked, this dish gives you a clear view. The non-porous surface resists stains and odors, making it easy to wipe clean. This dish is also dishwasher-safe, saving you time and effort.
Our Ratings
Overall Rating: 4.6/5 Ease Of Cleaning: 4.9/5 Durability: 4.8/5 Value for Money: 4.9/5 Ease of Use: 4.8/5 Ergonomic: 4.6/5
Materials | Glass |
Dimensions | 3.06 Inches (H) x 12.44 Inches (W) x 8.0 Inches (D) |
Capacity | 2 Qt |
Dishwasher Safe | yes |
Features | BPA-free, stain-resistant, microwave safe |
Pros:
Cons:
Xtrema Rectangular Baking Pan
Most Versatile
Source: Xtrema
Xtrema's Rectangular Baking Pan is a reliable addition to your daily cooking routine. Xtrema's commitment to healthy cooking is evident in this baking dish. Crafted from 100% ceramic material free from harmful substances like lead, cadmium, and toxic non-stick coatings, it ensures that no harmful chemicals leach into your food, providing you and your family with a safe and healthy cooking experience.
Each 100% ceramic baking dish is handmade by skilled Chinese artisans, and the durable ceramic material resists scratches and maintains its beauty and functionality over time. Cleaning is a breeze with the Ovenware Set, thanks to its non-stick surface that ensures effortless food release. Simply rinse or wipe it clean, and it's ready for your next culinary adventure.
This baking dish is a versatile kitchen companion, allowing you to explore a wide range of culinary creations. From lasagnas and casseroles to roasted vegetables and desserts, the Xtrema Ceramic Baking Dish can handle it all. You can explore your culinary creativity in the kitchen, thanks to its spacious dimensions and ample depth that can accommodate a wide range of recipes.
Our Ratings
Overall Rating: 4.6/5 Ease Of Cleaning: 4.9/5 Durability: 4.8/5 Value for Money: 4.9/5 Ease of Use: 4.8/5 Ergonomic: 4.6/5
Materials | 100% Pure ceramic |
Dimensions | 11.5" L x 9.5" W x 2.5" H 2 quart |
Capacity | 2, 4, or 6 quart |
Dishwasher Safe | yes |
Features | Free of PFOA and PFAS. No synthetic glues, polymers, dyes, or coatings |
Pros:
Cons:
Anchor Hocking Oven Basics Bake Dish
Best Deep Casserole Dish
Source: Amazon
The Anchor Hocking Basics Glass Baking Dish is the ultimate choice for home cooks seeking the best casserole dish with deep depth. This versatile bakeware combines exceptional quality, reliable performance, and the perfect size to accommodate your culinary creations. Unlike the other glass dishes, Anchor Hocking Basics Glass Baking Dish features a generous 8.2-inch depth that allows you to bake lasagna, meatball casserole, green bean casserole easily, and so much more.
The Anchor Hocking Basics Baking Dish is constructed using premium glass material, ensuring its durability for long-lasting use. Its sturdy construction withstands the test of time and delivers reliable performance, even with repeated use. The glass material of this baking dish offers excellent heat distribution, ensuring that your casseroles cook evenly from edge to center. No more worrying about undercooked or overcooked sections. Your favorite casserole dishes will emerge from the oven with a perfect golden-brown finish, especially the melted cheese and flavors harmoniously blended.
Our Ratings
Overall Rating: 4.5/5 Ease Of Cleaning: 4.7/5 Durability: 4.6/5 Value for Money: 4.4/5 Ease of Use: 4.5/5 Ergonomic: 4.4/5
Materials | Glass |
Dimensions | 11.5" L x 9.5" W x 2.5" H 2 quart |
Capacity | 5 quart |
Dishwasher Safe | yes |
Features | Dishwasher, microwave, freezer, and oven safe |
Pros:
Cons:
DaTerra Cucina Covered Roaster
Best Family-Friendly Casserole Dish
Source: Amazon
The DaTerra Cucina Covered Roaster is the ultimate choice for those seeking the best family-friendly size casserole dish. With its ideal dimensions, this roaster dish is specifically crafted to accommodate large, family-sized meals comfortably. With its generous capacity, you can easily prepare large batches of casseroles, roasts, or hearty dishes to share with your loved ones. This roaster ensures there's enough to go around, making it ideal for gatherings, celebrations, and creating cherished memories around the dinner table.
Crafted from a scratch-resistant non-stick surface and a thick 2.5 mm aluminum base that ensures effortless food release and easy cleanup. The non-stick coating also promotes healthier cooking by reducing the need for excess oils or fats. Enjoy delicious meals with less effort and less cleanup time. Additionally, the non-stick surface is free from harmful chemicals like PTFE, lead, and cadmium, prioritizing the safety of your family's meals.
Our Ratings
Overall Rating: 4.8/5 Ease Of Cleaning: 4.9/5 Durability: 4.6/5 Value for Money: 4.6/5 Ease of Use: 4.5/5 Ergonomic: 47/5
Materials | Ceramic Coated Aluminum |
Dimensions | 13 x 8 x 2.25 inches |
Capacity | N/A |
Dishwasher Safe | yes |
Features | Free of PTFE, lead, and cadmium |
Pros:
Cons:
How We Picked
We have meticulously selected our range of casserole dishes, drawing from our personal experiences, a thorough examination of customer reviews across multiple retail platforms, and invaluable input provided by home chefs. Our primary focus has been on essential factors like material quality, effortless cleaning, long-lasting durability, suitable size, and user-friendly design. This ensures that we exclusively recommend top-notch products to our valued readers.
