The 10 Best Non-Toxic Broiler Pans for Cooking Healthy, Hearty Meals

broiler pan

Last Updated - October 19, 2022

Best Overall
Five Two By Greenpan Roasting Pan thumbnail

 4.7/5

Most Versatile
Our Place Ovenware Set thumbnail

 5/5

Best Heavy Duty
Cuisinart Chef's Classic Lasagna Pan & Roasting Rack thumbnail

 4.8/5

Your oven broiler is an incredibly versatile cooking tool, but unfortunately, not every pan is up for the task. Stick to a broiler pan that's specially designed to withstand intense direct exposure to high temperatures. Pans that aren't broiler-safe may crack, warp, or melt, leaving you with a ruined meal and an annoying mess.

To ensure your meal is a success, we've rounded up ten of the best broiler pans on the market below. Here's some useful info to help you while you shop.

What Is A Broiler Pan?

A broiler pan is a baking tray made from durable materials that can withstand continuous exposure to these high temperatures. They commonly come with two baking trays: a deep roasting pan and a grate that nestles inside. Use them together for broiling or separately for baking, roasting, and serving.

The bottom roasting tray is larger and deeper than a traditional roasting pan. While it's ideal for everyday baking and roasting, it makes an excellent casserole dish too. When you're not busy grilling chicken and veggies, try making lasagna for your next dinner party.

What is a Broiler Pan Used For

Broiler pans are an excellent way to grill, sear, crisp, and roast food. During broiling, food is cooked at temperatures up to 550 degrees F. The pan is placed close to the heat source for a grill-like finish. Try using it for cooking:

  • Steaks, roasts, and other cuts of meat
  • Chicken, turkey, and other poultry
  • Vegetables

The pan's large size makes it easy to cook several meals at once. Place your meat on one side, your vegetables on the other, and a few peaches on the side for a delicious dessert.

Why You Should Be Using Non-Toxic Pans

Cookware labeled broiler-safe is typically made from aluminum, porcelain enamel, or stainless steel. High temperatures can glue on food particles, so look for products made with a nonstick coating that makes for easy cleaning. But did you know that traditional non-stick finishes contain PTFEs, PFAs, and other toxic chemicals?

Under the intense heat of your oven broiler, they can leach these toxins into your food. If you're shopping for a nonstick broiler pan, it's vital to narrow down your search to products labeled as non-toxic. Made without these dangerous materials, they're better for your health and the planet. Keep your broiling pan looking its best by avoiding sharp metal utensils and abrasive cleaners that can damage the non-stick finish.

Alternatively, try an oven broiler pan made from stainless steel. The reliable material won't absorb flavors or odors and won't warp or melt under high heat. Or, try broiling in your seasoned cast iron skillet.

The 10 Best Broiler Pans That Are Non-Toxic

Now that you've got a better sense of what you're looking for, it's time to start shopping. Here are 10 of the best broiler pan options on the market today.

Five Two By Greenpan Roasting Pan

Best Overall

Five Two By Greenpan Roasting Pan

Source: GreenPan

Love roasting veggies, baked cakes, lasagnas, and roasts? Try Five Two By Greenpan. The sturdy roasting pan is crafted from p3-ply stainless steel with excellent heat distribution and retention. Stainless steel rack will elevate your meat or vegetables above the drippings to create well-defined grill marks. Wide handles make it easy to grasp sizzling hot pans with bulky oven mitts. Use it on the grill, on the stovetop, in the oven, or under the broiler. Then, toss it in the dishwasher when you're done!

Pros:

  • Durable and heavy duty
  • Versatile
  • Oven safe up to 600˚F
  • Easy to clean, as it is dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • Expensive price tag

Our Place Ovenware Set

Most Versatile

Our Place Ovenware Set

Source: Our Place

This Ovenware Set from Our Place can do it all: broil, bake, braise, crisp, roast, sear, and serve, just to name a few! The bakeware set includes a versatile Oven Pan, three stoneware baking dishes, and a reusable Oven Mat. They're made using chip-resistant stoneware with a proprietary, non-toxic, non-stick coating. It's free from PFOAs, PTFEs, and other PFAs that may leak toxic materials into your food under the high heat of your oven broiler. Ergonomic side handles make it easy to maneuver heavy loads to and from the oven. Plus, the modular designs stack nearly together for compact storage.

Pros:

  • Food comes off easily and makes cleaning a breeze
  • Dishwasher safe
  • A stylish addition to your kitchen

Cons:

  • Expensive price point, but it is five piece set

Cuisinart Chef's Classic Lasagna Pan & Roasting Rack

Best Heavy Duty

Cuisinart Chef's Classic Lasagna Pan & Roasting Rack

Source: Target

Take your weeknight meals to the next level with this Cuisinart Chef's Classic Lasagna Pan and Roasting Rack. The 14-inch rectangular pan can be used to cook everything from lasagna to a whole chicken. Crafted from solid stainless steel, it's built to last through countless culinary adventures in the kitchen— especially thanks to a removable roasting rack. The deep bottom pan will safely catch foil and oil and result in a healthier meal. Spacious side handles offer a sturdy grip while carrying full pans to and from the oven. It's durable, versatile, and oven-safe up to 500 degrees. Plus, it's dishwasher safe for quick and easy clean-up once dinnertime is over.

Pros:

  • Oven safe up to 500 degrees
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Good size to cook chicken, ham, or lasagna
  • A versatile basic broiler pan
  • Heavy duty and heavy weight

Cons:

  • It can be heavy with the food inside

Cuisinart Chef's Classic Non-Stick Broiler Pan

Most Budget Friendly

Cuisinart Chef's Classic Non-Stick Broiler Pan

Source: Target

While the Cuisinart Chef's Classic Non-Stick Broiler Pan was designed with toaster ovens in mind, it can be used in your traditional oven too. Measuring 11 x 8.5 inches, it's perfect for small meals and studio apartments. The practical pan is crafted from heavy gauge stainless steel for even heating and excellent heat retention. The removable grate creates an extra-crispy exterior and a moist, juicy interior by elevating your chicken, fish, or meat above the drippings. The best part is that it's dishwasher-safe for quick clean-up after dinner. No matter what you're broiling, it's up for the task!

Pros:

  • Affordable price point
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • It can feel small, so be sure to look at the dimension before purchasing

Sur la Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan

Best Stainless Steel

Sur la Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan

Source: Amazon

At 12.25 x 9.5 inches, this Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan is perfect for small meals. Not to mention, its compact design makes for easy storage in kitchens with limited cabinet space. Crafted from durable stainless steel, it can withstand high oven temperatures and countless trips through the dishwasher. The two trays can also be used separately as a roasting or baking pan. Try using the upper grate to reheat leftover pizza without sacrificing a crispy crust.

Pros:

  • Affordable price point
  • Easy to clean
  • Easy to handle

Cons:

  • Sharp edges, so use with caution

Stock Your Home Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Pans

Best Disposable

Stock Your Home Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Pans

Source: Amazon

If you're cooking for a dinner party, backyard BBQ, or holiday gatherings, stick to these Disposable Aluminum Foil Broiler Pan from Stock Your Home. Each pack comes with ten 13 X 9-inch pans made of premium-quality aluminum that's lightweight, durable, and heat conductive. Rinse them off and recycle them for easy clean-up when the party is over. The ribbed bottom was specifically designed to give your meat or vegetables a grill-like texture.

But these disposable pans can do far more than broiling! Use them as serving trays or drip pans under your grill to catch grease and burnt food particles.

Pros:

  • Affordable price point
  • Great for broiling, grilling, and serving your food
  • Save a lot of scrubbing time

Cons:

  • Any food that is a little bit heavy will cause a sag in the middle

Caraway Baking Sheet

Best Baking Sheet

Caraway Baking Sheet

Source: Caraway

Short on cabinet space? This Caraway Baking Sheet is the only baking pan you'll need to make room for. It can bake, roast, and broil anything and everything on the menu, from garden-fresh vegetables to pork chops to chocolate chip cookies. Made using a non-toxic, mineral-based ceramic coating, it won't leach toxins into your food as it cooks. Plus, it's got a naturally slick cooking surface that hand washes clean in seconds. Choose between medium and large pans or purchase the duo set for $10 in savings. Once you try cooking with Caraway's signature non-stick material, you'll never go back to your old pans again!

Pros:

  • Food comes off easily
  • Good size
  • Lightweight
  • Very luxurious from start to finish

Cons:

  • Pricey price tag

Wildone Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack Set

Best Value

Wildone Baking Sheet with Cooling Rack Set

Source: Amazon

This Baking Sheet and Cooling Rack Set from Wildone makes an excellent choice for entertaining. The six-piece set includes three different sizes of baking sheets and cooling racks made of high-quality 18/0 stainless steel. It's made without toxic chemicals and with deep, rolled edges that keep drippings, sauces, and other liquids inside. The multi-purpose metal grates can be used for broiling foods in the oven or cooling them on the counter once they come out. Needless to say, your dinner guests will be impressed with your cooking skills and jealous of your cookware repertoire.

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • Great size. Perfect for roasting meats and vegetables

Cons:

  • Can scratch easily

Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set

Best For Convenience

Norpro Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set

Source: Amazon

Norpro's Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set makes healthy cooking easy! The two-piece set features a 17-inch rectangular broiler pan and a top grate made of strong, durable stainless steel. Simple yet effective, the perforated design lets grease drain off for crisp, juicy final results with lower fat content. Its large pan size is perfect for entertaining and meal-prepping. With countless ways to use them, these practical trays are a worthy addition to any kitchen. Try making one giant batch of roasted chicken breast and olive oil-rubbed vegetables for dinner on Sunday, and you'll have leftovers for lunch all week long.

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Lightweight

Cons:

  • Pricey price tag
  • Edges are sharp

Granite Ware 3-Piece Broiling Set

Best For Less Fat Broiling

Granite Ware 3-Piece Broiling Set

Source: Amazon

If you plan to use your broiler pan primarily for cooking steaks, chicken, and other meat, go with this 3-Piece Broiling Set from Granite Ware. It includes a 14 X 9-inch roasting pan with a grill rack and a perforated tray made from porcelain fused steel. The non-toxic, chip-resistant material is naturally non-stick and dishwasher-safe. Use the perforated tray for cooking steaks, vegetables, or fish filets and the drip tray to catch grease and keep the bottom of your oven clean. Don't be afraid to get adventurous in the kitchen. Its deep design makes it an excellent lasagna pan too!

Pros:

  • Easy to clean but may require a little effort
  • Sturdy
  • Bake, broil, gas or charcoal grill

Cons:

  • Can scratch easily

Disclaimer: This post includes affiliate links. This means I make a few dollars if you purchase/sign up after clicking my link. This costs you nothing, but it helps keep this blog running!


You may also like

heart veggie

Be A Happier & Healthier You

Start Your Self Care Journey Today And Get A FREE Weekly Self Care Check List 

>